He may have seen the suffering that she went through, but it is evident that he had some sort of strange love for his daughter. While I have never experienced living with someone who is severely disabled, I have had the chance to discuss the issue with many friends and associates.
In an outrageous decision by the Parole Board of Canada, on December 7,Latimer was denied day parole after 7 years in prison, on the grounds that he was uncomfortable with personal questions, unrepentant, in need of rehabilitation, and a threat to the public.
He said the law "recognizes that the moral culpability or the moral blameworthiness of murder can vary from one convicted offender to another. In conclusion, the minimum mandatory sentence is Robert latimer case essay disproportionate in this case.
An acquittal for Robert Latimer would be a declaration that such Robert latimer case essay are proper for anyone who has a child living with similar disabilities.
Thus, it would seem either extremely difficult for a jury to make a reasonable call on whether or not Latimer should have been guilty. Her involuntary movements started to create strain in her muscles, and when she was four years old she had her first operation, cutting some muscles to relieve tension.
However, that decision was overturned two months later, and Latimer was ultimately released for day parole on March 13, To be able to conduct a prosperous study, the concentration and efforts should be maximized. Our system of laws is right in finding that to legalize euthanasia would far a massive risk upon the elderly, sick, and disabled of our society.
It was a fair sentence when all aspects of the case are considered. Supreme Court hears appeal. Will ten years in prison change the way Latimer feels about his actions? About this resource This coursework was submitted to us by a student in order to help you with your studies.
And the anti-convulsant medication conflicted with pain relievers, so that for all the pain Tracy was subsequently to endure the strongest analgesic she could ever take was Tylenol 2. But we cannot allow personal characteristics and special circumstances of the case to supersede the gravity of the act.
Does the killer really want to put the victim out of their misery? I believe in balancing all compassionate factors involved when deciding what is just in a murder case.
His defense that such an action was the necessary and his responsibility in order to prevent the pain and suffering that Tracy would have been forced to endure. Another surgery was carried out, this time major surgery lasting 7 to 8 hours, inserting long steel rods into her back to try to straighten her out.
Seizures started as soon as she regained consciousness, likely causing more brain damage. Whether the victim valued her existence or not, we must remain aware of the need to respect the life, dignity and equality of anyone affected by such an act.
In the Latimer case I will argue not that hard cases make bad laws, but that bad laws make hard cases. And, during this long journey, here are some of the things that happened to him: Our system of laws is right in finding that to legalize euthanasia would far a massive risk upon the elderly, sick, and disabled of our society.
It is instead a question of justice being served. One of the strong questions raised in my mind is: Should the sentence be a harsher one? As well, the quality of her life was limited by her severe disability. Latimer's second trial begins. The charging, conviction and sentencing of Latimer was more lenient than that provided to any other convicted murderer.
From what I have learned, it is, indeed, an extremely tough matter to deal with. Minimum Sentences essaysThe case of Robert Latimer, the Saskatchewan farmer who killed his disabled daughter Tracy, Robert latimer case essay once again brought into focus the issue of mandatory minimum sentences MMS.
Saskatchewan Court of Appeal decides to uphold Latimer conviction. Speaking more than 10 years after he ran a hose from the exhaust to the cab of his pickup truck and put his daughter Tracy inside to die, Latimer says he still believes he did the right thing.
Whether the victim valued her existence or not, we must remain aware of the need to respect the life, dignity and equality of anyone affected by such an act. But the movements continued to take a toll, and began to give Tracy serious levels of pain. Laura Latimer had an uneventful pregnancy, but not so for the birth.
This was then overturned, on legal grounds, by the appeal court — by people who had not attended the trial. Jury finds Latimer guilty of second-degree murder and recommends he be eligible for parole after one year. Possibly, euthanasia should be considered cold-blooded first-degree style murder, with a full life sentence without parole.
That is why for want of a better term this is called compassionate homicide.Case study Halina Paerhati Despite the public’s belief that Robert Latimer’s mandatory minimum 10 years sentence to be “cruel and unusual punishment”, I personally am satisfied with this sentence.
Latimer Case Essay Sample. Despite the public’s belief that Robert Latimer’s mandatory minimum 10 years sentence to be “cruel and unusual punishment”, I personally am satisfied with this sentence. Euthanasia and the Robert Latimer Case Euthanasia is undoubtedly an issue that plagues the minds of those living with children or adults who are severely disabled.
Rarely is one found to have a neutral' outlook upon it; that is, a side must be chosen, for or against. An undated photo of Robert Latimer and his daughter Tracy at home. ((Maclean's/Canadian Press)) Tracy was a pound quadriplegic, a year-old who functioned at the level of a three-month-old.
JR'S Free Thought Pages No Gods ~ No Masters The Case of Robert Latimer: Punishing Acts of Mercy.
By Gary Bauslaugh. Humanist Perspectives, Spring We can often get away with evil acts, but a good one will haunt us forever. - Gilbert Ryle. The Law is an ass when it inadvertently causes an injustice.
Free coursework on Euthanasia And The Robert Latimer Case from agronumericus.com, the UK essays company for essay, dissertation and coursework writing.Download